Detailed Record



Counterfactuals in mainstream media: A pathway for blame attribution and policy endorsement in police lethal force incidents


Abstract Previous research demonstrates that exposure to police lethal force through the media impacts individuals' support for police reform, but the mechanism driving this support is underexplored. The current study examines how news media counterfactuals (i.e., creating alternative outcomes for events that have already occurred) influence individuals' processing of police lethal force incidents, and how these perceptions, in turn, impact support for police reform. In a 2 (victim race: Black vs. White) × 3 (counterfactual target: victim, officer, or no counterfactual control) factorial design, 925 participants read a news article summarizing a lethal force incident, assigned blame for both the officer and victim, and reported their endorsement for various police reforms. Results indicated counterfactual target impacted blame attributions, and these blame attributions predicted endorsement of police reform while controlling for Attitudes Towards Police Legitimacy (APLS). These findings illustrate how media counterfactuals can influence blame, and importantly, influence perceptions of various police reforms.
Authors Olivia K. H. Smith ORCID , Narina Nuñez University of WyomingORCID
Journal Info Wiley-Blackwell | Applied Cognitive Psychology , vol: 38 , iss: 3
Publication Date 5/1/2024
ISSN 0888-4080
TypeKeyword Image article
Open Access hybrid Hybrid Access
DOI https://doi.org/10.1002/acp.4219
KeywordsKeyword Image Police Legitimacy (Score: 0.568171) , Community Policing (Score: 0.540443) , Police Culture (Score: 0.513996)